Who is John Yates?

Last week the Bahrain Government announced they would be hiring a former Assistant Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police Force to help oversee ‘reform’ of their Police; this man is John Yates.

Dubbed “Yates of the Yard” by the British press, he is most known in Britain for his dubious role in the phone hacking scandal that resulted in his eventual resignation.

In 2006 Yates was in charge of an inquiry into the alleged hacking of the phones of British Royal Family members by journalists at The News of The World. It resulted in the swift imprisonment of 2 men.

This then marked the end of the investigation and little more was said on the matter until 3 years later when Yates was asked to review the original investigation in light of new evidence that there were other victims of phone hacking.

However, he restated that the original investigation was “satisfactory” and no further action was taken.

But earlier this year the scandal burst back into life after evidence was published that phone hacking was a regular offence being committed at The News of The World, forcing the paper to close.

This raised the very serious question as to why Yates had repeatedly said there were no further cases of phone hacking when it was clear that Police had evidence of a “vast number of victims”.

Give his new role with the Bahraini Royal Family it is interesting to note that Yates was very quick to charge the 2 men who had been involved in the hacking of phones owned by the British Royal Family, but was far less concerned with other cases.

Yates came under a huge amount of pressure to resign, including from a number of MP’s. One such MP, Chris Bryant claimed ‘a very dirty smell’ surrounded the Police Force in this matter.

In July Yates released a statement admitting mistakes had been made but denying any suggestions of corruption or improper conduct.

Does this sort of statement sound familiar to those listening to the Bahrain Government recently? Hmmmm.

Despite Yates’ protests of innocence, 9 days after this statement he resigned. (We can only hope the Government of Bahrain will do this.)

So what does this episode tell us about John Yates? Here is a man who was forced from his position for allegedly hiding evidence from the public, lying to Parliament and failing to prosecute anyone except for those going against the Royal Family.

This doesn’t bode particularly well for his future with Bahrain.

But the controversies do not stop there. Perhaps more interestingly in 2009 Yates was put in charge of overseeing the investigation of allegations against UK anti-terrorism officers, accused of torturing Guantanamo Bay Detainee Binyam Mohamed.

After over a year it was announced that there would be no charges against an MI5 officer who Mohamed claimed was aware of his torture.

So allegations of torture but no charges and no one found responsible. So far ticking all the boxes to work in Bahrain.

It can also be said that Yates’ time as Assistant Commissioner to the Metropolitan Police coincided with heavy-handed tactics being used by the police force against demonstrations.

In the past couple of years London Police have come under attack for increasingly aggressive tactics on demonstrations, most notably in April 2009 when Mark Tomlinson died after being hit by a Police Officer during the protests against the G20.

Clearly we cannot know the role, if any, of John Yates in developing a more brutal strategy for the Metropolitan Police but if he was in such a prominent position he would have had the ability to protest against heavy-handed tactics.

Surely the Bahrain Government should be looking at hiring individuals who were in charge of organizations with a reputation for recognizing human rights and not those who stand accused of their own violations.

Yates also held responsibility for overseeing Britain’s counter terrorism strategy. Considering Bahrain’s description of protesters as “terrorists”, perhaps this was another reason why they chose him for the role.

Bahrain Hiring a former officer with a less than perfect track record has not been limited just to John Yates. They have also hired former Miami Police Chief, John Timoney, who is accused of being the architect behind brutal policing of demonstrations in the US.

This appointment of these two individuals has pretty much been the only action-based response from Bahrain to the Independent Commission of Inquiry, which provided a damning assessment of their treatment of pro-democracy demonstrations.

Even if Yates and Timoney were considered the perfect example of respectable and fair policing, it still wouldn’t be enough to prove that Bahrain is taking reform seriously.

It’s not just the police that needs reforming it is the whole political system, starting at the very top.

And let’s be honest, neither Yates nor Timoney are whiter than white.

Did you like this? Share it: