Reaction to BICI implementation 1 year on

One year on from the publication of the critical Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry, those inside and outside of the country have taken the opportunity to judge the level of implementation and progress made by the Government so far. Opposition societies, NGO’s, Governments and even the former head of the commission have all reacted and the general consensus has been that implementation has not been satisfactory. Below we summarise most of the reactions to take place so far:

Leading opposition society, Al Wefaq, released a report entitled “Selective Implementations and Fake Commitment”. It argues that the most important recommendations remained without implementation, such as ending impunity amongst high ranking officials accused of torture and other mistreatments. In a press conference in Bahrain Sayed Hadi Almusawi, Head of Al Wefaq’s Human Rights Section, said that violations have increased since the BICI, rather than stopped.”

Meanwhile in London, another resigned MP from Al Wefaq, Ali Alaswad, told members of the press that Bahrain “is further away than ever before” from reconciliation, as a result of “Government violations and a lack of implementation.”

Resigned MP Ali Alaswad speaks to media in London

He added that the BICI should not have taken one year to be implemented saying “the recommendations are modest and easy to do”. He argued that the attitude of “give us time and we will do it soon” was no longer acceptable and a lack of political will is stopping full implementation now.

A joint report from the Bahrain Centre for Human rights with Bahrain Rehabilitation & Anti-Violence Organization (BRAVO) and the Bahrain Youth Society for Human Rights (BYSHR) expressed similar sentiments.  The report, entitled “The BICI reforms: Promises of Progress, a Worsening Reality”, claims that whilst the Government has had “ample time to act but in general has only made superficial progress.”

The BBC reported on a meeting in The Hague, where the International Criminal Court is based, in which members of the opposition outlined that the Government had failed to deliver on implementing the BICI report.

Outside of Bahrain, many groups have issued reports or statements. Notably the Project on Middle East Democracy (POMED) assess implementation, recommendation by recommendation, claiming that only 3 have been fully implemented, whilst the most important 6 remain untouched.

Amnesty Internationals latest report “Reform shelved, repression unleashed” has been widely acclaimed, receiving good media coverage. It serves to show that key recommendations remain unmet, whilst repression has increased in the past few months, in direct contradiction with the BICI. It ends with a number of recommendations that include:

  • Immediately and unconditionally release all prisoners of conscience imprisoned solely for peacefully exercising their human rights to freedom of expression, association and assembly.
  • Immediately lift the ban on all protests
  • Ensure that security forces policing demonstrations or performing other law enforcement duties comply fully with the UN Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials and the UN Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials;
  • Publicly condemn the practice of torture and other ill-treatment and declare unequivocally that such violations will not be tolerated;
In addition to our own timeline of violations since the BICI, Americans for Democracy and Human rights put out two publications that both argue that the BICI is far from being fully implemented. Meanwhile Brian Dooley of Human Rights First wrote that Bahrain’s reforms remain shallow promises.
US based Human Rights Watch also responded to the BICI with a long statement entitled “Promises Unkept, Rights still violated”. Importantly they conducted an interview with the former head of the BICI, Mr. Cherif Bassiouni, who was hugely critical of the progress made by the Government. Below is the section of the statement that contains Bassiouni’s damning comments, which will no doubt come as a major blow to Government attempts at claiming that major progress has been made:

Mr. Cherif Bassiouni, former BICI Head

“A number of recommendations on accountability were either not implemented or implemented only half-heartedly,” Bassiouni said. “The public prosecution has yet to investigate over 300 cases of alleged torture, some involving deaths in custody, and there has been no investigation, let alone prosecution, for command responsibility, even at the immediate supervisory level, of people killed in custody as a result of torture.”

The public prosecution has announced investigations into allegations of wrongdoing involving  over 150 cases involving government personnel and charges against 56, including some 122 cases referred by the Interior Ministry, according to the official Information Affairs Authority. As far as Human Rights Watch has been able to determine, four have been convicted of an offense and at least three acquitted. The most severe sentence was seven years for a police lieutenant convicted of killing Hani Abd al-Aziz Jumaa with shotgun blasts fired at close range. In another case a policeman convicted in the shotgun shooting of an anti-government protester was sentenced to five years in prison, reduced on appeal to three years.

“You can’t say that justice has been done when calling for Bahrain to be a republic gets you a life sentence and the officer who repeatedly fired on an unarmed man at close range only gets seven years,” Bassiouni said.

Following the release of the report, the king established the National Commission to monitor the government’s implementation of the recommendations. The National Commission ended its work on March 20, and concluded that implementation was “comprehensive and far reaching” and “touched all aspects of Bahraini life.”

King Hamad’s decision to establish the independent commission was “courageous and far reaching,” Bassiouni said, but the conviction of Rajab, for example, illustrated “a pattern of continued prosecution of individuals solely for exercising rights protected by international human rights law, something King Hamad promised to bring to an end.”

Regarding many cases in which Bahrain’s highest court affirmed convictions despite credible allegations of torture, Bassiouni said that the rulings were “legally unsound,” citing one case in which the court declared the defendant’s confession admissible because it was taken several days after the torture occurred.

“I cannot think of a more egregious and specious legal opinion – admitting that the torture occurred but ruling the confession admissible and allowing the conviction to stand,” he said. “This constitutes a violation of the Convention Against Torture, to which Bahrain is a party.”

In line with the BICI recommendations, King Hamad stripped the National Security Agency of its powers to arrest and detain, and established a Special Investigation Unit in the Public Prosecution Office to look into allegations of unlawful deaths and torture. Bassiouni told Human Rights Watch that the seven-person unit is not working full-time on these cases, and has not conducted independent investigations. “The special unit does not have investigators or forensic experts on its staff,” he said. “This is a capacity problem that can and should be corrected.”

The US State Department took the step of arranging a special press briefing on the subject in which it said “we remain concerned about increasing violence in Bahrain, by limits on free expression and assembly, and a political environment that’s become increasingly difficult and that’s made reconciliation and political dialogue more difficult.”

Specifically on the BICI, whilst they said some recommendations had been implemented they added, “and what unfortunately hasn’t happened is that on a range of issues, including the one you just raised – accountability – some of the things [Senior Administration Official Two] talked about, on the hardest issues the government has not followed through and we’ve not seen – there are still people who are being held in prison or being prosecuted for demonstrating a year and a half ago, for expressing their political views. There’s still not meaningful police reform. So there are a range of ways in which the society is waiting for those actions which would begin to bring the country together.”

In a statement following a meeting with the Bahraini Foreign Minister, UK Foreign Secretary William Hague said, “It is critical that the Bahraini Government continues to address concerns about human rights, through further implementation of the Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry and Universal Periodic Review recommendations, to help provide the right environment for national dialogue to take place.” This is a clear acceptance that the BICI implementation still needs a lot of work doing.

With wide ranging criticism the Government of Bahrain itself launched it’s own review, which was unsurprisingly more positive. It claims that progress has been made and is still ongoing and on track. Read Marc Owen-Jones, who eloquently comments on the Government’s review.

Separately, the Minister of Justice felt the need to respond to the many reports from NGO’s, calling them “baseless”.

Generally speaking the reaction from the international community has been that little progress has really been made. Countless examples of ongoing violations have been cited and even Bahrain’s allies have been unable to provide a positive assessment.

The BICI was a comprehensive report that clearly highlighted violations and abuses carried out by Bahrain. But it will only truly be a worthwhile exercise if it takes the country forward, which can only happen with full and immediate implementation. The Government of Bahrain needs to end the process of stalling, whilst continuing the same violations highlighted by the report and stop paying -lip-service to the BICI. Actions speak louder than words and at the moment the action of the Bahrain Government are speaking only of repression, violence and a refusal to reform.

 

Did you like this? Share it: