A group of Bahraini’s, including human rights activists, politicians, former detainees and others, attended the 22nd session of the Human Rights Council in Geneva last week, to shed light on the ongoing human rights violations in Bahrain.
The delegation spoke in side events, held meetings with international NGO’s and UN officials, and hosted a week long exhibition outside the main UN building. One highlight of the week was a meeting held by the High Commissioner for Human Rights, Ms. Navi Pillay, in which she answered questions on Bahrain and made clear that it would continue to be a focus of her office’s attention. Our full report on the event is below:
Bahraini civil society members meet with UN High Commissioner
Navi Pillay, the High Commissioner on Human Rights, said that Bahrain would be a focus of her office’s attention, speaking to NGO members in Geneva.
During the 22nd session of the Human Rights Council, the High Commissioner held a special meeting with NGO’s that she described as a “valuable opportunity for a direct exchange”.
During the one-hour meeting, two Bahraini women spoke from the floor about the ongoing human rights abuses in Bahrain. Ms. Bushra Alhendi and Dr. Nada Dhaif addressed the High Commissioner and raised concerns of violations against freedom of speech and expression, torture and the recent killing of two young men.
Both asked for a permanent office of the High Commission in Bahrain and asked for feedback from the visit to Bahrain of her office in December.
In response Ms. Pillay made clear her offices’ concern about the situation in Bahrain and assured that it “will continue to be a focus of attention for my office”. She said that her office is pushing the matter in their “usual way” as confirmed by the Head of the Middle East Section Mr. Hany Megally who said they are engaging with Bahrain officials on a number of issues, including the stripping of nationalities.
Mr. Megally added that accountability for abuses is also a key area of work for the office and said that we want to engage with Bahrain in order to see progress. He also said he was “heartened by dialogue” and hopes that it will continue.
Ms. Alhendi highlighted that although dialogue is happening, the human rights violations are continuing in Bahrain.
The High Commissioner also took the opportunity to salute Dr. Nada Dhaif for treating injured protesters and for her brave stand as a human tights defender in Bahrain.
On the key area of a permanent office in Bahrain, Ms. Pillay stated that the visit in December was a “first step” in deciding if they wish to have a permanent office in Bahrain, adding that this visit was to assess the situation and meet with officials and members of civil society.
Apologies for poor sound on the following two videos:
The delegation from Bahrain also took part in two side events, one on Monday 11th March and the other on Friday 15th March. In the session on the Monday, hosted by the Khiam Centre for Rehabilitation of Torture victims, discussed ongoing allegations of torture and the lack of punishment for perpetrators. Torture victims Sheikh Maytham Al Salman and Mohammed Altajer (who has also defended victims in court) were joined by Said Yousif Almuhafdah, who had that day heard the news that he had been acquitted in his case of “publishing false news via Twitter”.
The second side event was hosted by CIVICUS, No Peace Without Justice and supported by many other NGO’s. Read our full report below:
BICI Commissioner calls for full implementation in UN side event
Sir Nigel Rodley, a lead Commissioner of the Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry (BICI), said he would like to see more implementation of the inquiry’s recommendations, speaking to a large audience at the Human Rights Council in Geneva.
He joined a panel that included Bahraini’s Dr. Nada Dhaif, Maryam Alkhawaja, Mohammed Alboflasa and Yacoob Sayeedi, as well as a representative from the International Human Rights Federation (FIDH) and the Chair Ms. Renate Bloem from CIVICUS. The event was jointly hosted by CIVICUS, The Bahrain Centre for Human Rights, BRAVO and supported by a number of other international human rights organisations.
A number of key figures were also present in the audience including, Laura Dupuy Lassere, the previous President to the Human Rights Council who famously criticised the Bahrain Government delegation during the Universal Periodic Review in May 2012. Resigned Bahraini MP Sayed Hadi Almusawi was also present, along with key figures from various UN bodies in Geneva.
Sir Nigel Rodley spoke first highlighting some background to the BICI, describing it as both “exciting” and a “hard task”. He described the situation in Bahrain at the beginning of the Commission as “very serious” with cases of killings, torture, mass arrests, dismissals, expulsions from schools and university and more.
Sir Nigel highlighted 3 key areas from the recommendations, although admitted he was unable to provide a full assessment on how much reform there has been on those issues. He made clear that a main issue of concern was accountability and that he felt that it has not yet gone to the highest level, and therefore “impunity was a prevailing issue of concern”.
He also said that the Commission had wanted all peaceful political prisoners released and clearly that had not yet happened, with some still serving lengthy sentences.
The third area he addressed was the integration of a fair representation of Bahrain into the security forces, saying reports that the Government may be committing to this was positive but it needs to be done in full to restore faith between people and the security services.
Sir Nigel was encouraged by the current dialogue that is taking place and felt that it should not be jeopardised by anyone hostile to the process. Although he added that human rights should “not be held hostage to the dialogue” and that they needed to respected in their own right away from any negotiations.
He concluded by saying that the BICI needs more implementation and that victims of violations should be compensated whilst violators must be brought to justice.
His speech was followed by Dr. Nada Dhaif who highlighted the human rights violations that have taken place over the past 2 years and continue to happen to this day. Her message to the audience was that they could play a role in helping Bahrain and that she did not “want their pity, but their support”.
Yacoob Sayeedi spoke about the current national dialogue and provided some areas of concern about the process and its ability to deliver, whilst Julie Gromellon from FIDH spoke about the case of human rights defender Nabeel Rajab and the work her organisation has been doing to defend Rajab
Mohamed Alboflasa, the first political detainee of the 14th February uprising, spoke about his arrest, as well as providing thoughts on the current situation and information on ongoing human rights violations. Maryam Alkhawaja spoke last and called for four areas of action. She wanted to see full implementation of the BICI, a fact finding mission from the Human Rights Council to Bahrain, for Bahrain to accept a permanent office of the Office of the High Commissioner and for the EU to hold companies to account who sell equipment to Bahrain used for repression.
Speaking from the floor, after the panellists, Laura Dupuy Lassere, Former President of the Human Rights Council, made clear her ongoing concerns about Bahrain and said that any steps taken by Bahrain need to lead to real solutions to the crisis in the country.
Resigned MP Sayed Hadi Almusawi mentioned that the level of trust between the people and the Government had broken down and that the Government had attempted to divert political problems into human rights violation.
The delegation also held meetings with a number of high-level officials from the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner on Human Rights, including Mr. Frej Fenniche, the Head of the Middle East and North Africa Section and Ms. June Ray Head of the Civil Society Section. In their discussions with Ms. Ray, the delegation informed about the new draft law being proposed in Bahrain that would give massive powers to the Minister for Social Affairs over civil society. They warned that the new law would enable the Minister to shut down political societies, reject NGO’s and even dissolve current groups. Human rights lawyer Mohammed Altajer said, “There is a danger that this could be passed through Parliament at any time, given that there is no real opposition in the Parliament at the moment.” They also discussed the lack of Government funding available for civil society in Bahrain.
Members of the delegation also met with representatives of the UN special rapporteurs for torture, extra-judicial killings, human rights defenders and freedom of association and assembly. During these meetings the staff informed of a section on the OHCHR website that showed all correspondances from their office to the Government of Bahrain and the replies. The most recent can be read here. Below is one example of issues raised by the OHCHR with Bahrain and the reply from the Government afterwards.
UN issues raised with Bahrain:
Allegations of repeated restrictions on the right to freedom of peaceful assembly, arbitrary detention and excessive use of force during demonstrations. According to the information received, several demonstrations have been either denied authorization by the relevant authorities or met with excessive use of force by law enforcement officials. Ms. Zahra Salman AlSheikh Ali, a 21 year old female student, was allegedly arrested. On 22 June 2012, a few members of Al Wefaq National Islamic Society, one of the largest opposition groups, attempted to stage a demonstration, but riot police fired large amounts of sound grenades, rubber bullets, and shotguns from close range, seriously injuring tens of protesters and opposition leaders, including Mr. Ali Salman, President of Al Wefaq National Islamic Society, Mr. Hassan Marzouk, Deputy Secretary General of the National Democratic Unionist Assembly, resigned MP Mr. Jawad Fairoos, as well as Mr. Ali Mohd Jafar AlMowali and Mr. Sayed Hameed Sayed Adnan. Messrs. Sayed Hadi Sayed Ebrahim, AbdulRedha Hasan Salman, Elyas Husain Ali Rajab, Sayed Hameed Sayed Adnan, Jafar Ahmed AlHamran and Ali Khalil Mirza were reportedly arrested during the event and charged with illegal gathering. Allegedly, a number of other participants were also arrested and charged with illegal gathering.
Click here to read the lengthy response from the Government of Bahrain
A number of those visiting from Bahrain also took the opportunity to meet with Geneva based NGO’s and rights groups, including the Association for Prevention of Torture, Inter-Parliamentary Union, and many other local groups on a wide range of issues.
Activists in BRAVO arranged a week long exhibition about Bahrain’s political prisoners and martyrs, outside the United Nations HQ. Our report below:
Bahrain stand outside UN Human Rights Council
Bahraini human rights activists have arranged an exhibition tent outside the United Nations Human Rights Council in Geneva.
During the 22nd session of the human rights council activists in BRAVO have created a display with images of those killed in the past 2 years, at the site of the famous “broken chair”.
It also shows pictures of the improvised medics and human rights defenders, aiming to raise awareness about the ongoing human rights violations in Bahrain.
Dr Nada Dhaif of BRAVO said, “The purpose is to highlight the extra judicial killings and the victims who died at the hands of the government. The banners also show the two major cases we want to highlight in Geneva, the medics and the Human Rights Defenders.”
The stand also served as a focal point for a protest calling for freedom for Nabeel Rajab. Watch the video below:
Dr. Nada Dhaif, Chairperson of BRAVO and imprisoned medic also had the chance to speak in the Human Rights Council itself, as shown in the video below:
The week long visit enjoyed a busy schedule of meetings, in which the delegation from Bahrain did their best to highlight the ongoing human rights violations, lack of reforms, countering the constant presence the Government has in Geneva.













