Alistair Burt, UK Foreign Office Minister for the Middle East and North Africa, took part in a question and answer session on twitter about Bahrain, reaffirming the UK position towards Bahrain.
The Minister answered a number of questions covering the role of their Ambassador, Iranian involvement, BICI implementation and torture. Twitter users took to the hashtag “#AskFCO” to question the Minister and scrutinise the policy of UK towards Bahrain.
During the session Burt admitted that prevention of torture in Bahrain is a top priority, a sign that UK is aware that allegations and evidence of torture is still ongoing despite promises made by the Government of Bahrain. Burt argued that the best way to deal with torture is for the UK to share their experiences and knowledge with Bahrain in order to help the prevention of torture.
@stevedigits Torture prevention a priority. Sharing experience of inspecting detention facilities & national preventative mechanism #OPCAT.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
Recent criticism of comments made by the UK ambassador in Bahrain led to a number of questions about his role.
@alistairburtfco is the British ambassador playing with or against the demand for an elected gov in #Bahrain? #askfco
— mohd noaman (@mohdnoaman) April 8, 2013
@alistairburtfco according to UK ambassador there is a good progress on reforms. Does UK agree with this?#askFCO
— JaffarAlaswad (@Alaswad87) April 8, 2013
@alistairburtfco Why your ambassador ignore the hundreds of thousands calling for democracy & talk about Iran backing the movement?#AskFCO
— Bu Emad (@Bu_Emmad) April 8, 2013
Burt defended his Ambassador by stating there was “clear evidence” that the UK listens to all sides
@elhashimi1 Ambassador & HMG talks to all sides, essential to listen to all views on complex issues, clear evidence we do.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
Part of the controversy around the interview the Ambassador gave to Gulf Daily News was centred around his claims that Iran was involved in protests in Bahrain. Burt admitted that the BICI gave no evidence but said UK is now concerned by growing evidence of Iran supporting some “radical opposition” and that foreign interference is unacceptable.
@bu_emmad 1/2 No clear evidence of Iranian involvement in 2011 unrest. But concerned Iran & others now supporting some radical opposition.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
@bu_emmad 2/2 Any foreign interference would be unacceptable. Important people of Bahrain decide their future for themselves.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
He did not, however, mention interference of other states in Bahrain, including Saudi Arabia, leading some to question the Minister further.
@alistairburtfco @bu_emmad Are you sure you don’t mean any foreign interference apart from Saudi, US and UK which is taken as given? #askFCO
— John Lubbock (@jwsal) April 8, 2013
@alistairburtfco Do you consider Saudi interference as unacceptable as Iranian interference? #AskFCO
— Dominic Kavakeb (@DominicKavakeb) April 8, 2013
The implementation of the BICI was a key area of discussion during the session, with many decrying the lack of progress made by Bahrain.
@alistairburtfco #askFCO What is #UK view of implementation of #BICI? Do you agree with Bassiouni that it has been inadequate? #Bahrain
— fouad Ibrahim (@fuadibrahim2011) April 8, 2013
@alistairburtfco Why r BICI’s recommendations regarding Ebrahim Sharif and the rest of pol. Leaders ignored #askFCO: ow.ly/jFdVw
— أم شريف (@Farida_Ghulam) April 7, 2013
@alistairburtfco bahrain regieme didnt implement bici recomendation, still u support dictatorship against people demand 4 democracy #askfco
— Ali Al Fayez (@ALFAYEZ313) April 8, 2013
In response, Burt affirmed the UK position that they are pleased with some progress that has been made but are still looking for further implementation in a number of areas, including on accountability, media and the integration of all Bahrainis into the security services.
@alfayez313 1/2 Welcome steps taken so far on BICI: establishing police ombudsman & special investigations unit & review of military trials.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
@alfayez313 2/2 Still have concerns in some areas: openness of media, integration of security forces and accountability for human rights.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
Burt said he also discussed the BICI in his recent visit to Bahrain, where he encouraged dialogue, urged BICI implementation and offered UK assistance in key areas. He outlined who from the opposition he had met with during the trip, that included Al Wefaq, National Unity Assembly, Independents and NGO’s.
@ally1611 Encouraged the Dialogue vital to a Bahraini solution. Urged further BICI implimentation & offered assistance to help process.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
@ally1611 Meet with wide variety of groups including Al Wefaq, National Unity Assembly, Independents & human rights NGOs.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
During the discussion, the Minister expressed his agreement with the sentiments of the group “Citizens for Bahrain”, who have been active recently in criticising the opposition, accusing them of acts of terrorism and violence. Burt agreed with them that violence (amongst protesters) is a negative thing, something the UK has consistently said for some time.
@citizensforbh Agree. Issues complex. Can only be addressed through dialogue. Violence has no place in resolving differences.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
This led to many questioning the role of the UK in relation to the human rights violations committed by the Police against peaceful protesters. Burt answered a question on whether the UK is supplying Bahrain with arms to aid this repression, but he defended the UK safeguards that he says prevents such outcomes.
@sadeqalwahab UK arms control one of toughest in world. Open to Parliament and public scrutiny. Clear safeguards ensure our criteria met.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
He also made clear that reforms should lead to progress in human rights, citing the appointment of the Crown Prince to Deputy Prime Minister as a positive reform.
@igandh UK welcomes CP’s appointment. We are clear that reform should support serious progress on #humanrights issues.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
Hassiba HadjSahraoui, from Amnesty International, asked the Minister about the political prisoners in Bahrain and what the UK was doing to help their release? The Minister took the opportunity to make clear that UK raises concerns on this issue with Bahrain and pushes for “proper judicial process” in all cases.
@hassibahs UK steadfast in urging proper judicial process. Has raised concerns & cases where this process has allegedly not been followed.
— Alistair Burt (@AlistairBurtFCO) April 8, 2013
Dozens of other questions were asked covering a range of issues, but with only 45 minutes for the Q&A there was always going to be a lot left unanswered. None-the-less the session provided a great opportunity for Bahrainis and non-Bahrainis alike to question the UK Government and make clear their opinions of the role UK has played. There was very little said that hasn’t already been made clear by UK statements, but it may offer some solace to Bahrainis that Alistair Burt is following the situation and aware of many of the criticisms Bahrainis have about UK policy.